gaming, public outreach, web resources
Knee operation, anyone?
I performed my fist knee operation today. Not in real life though but on my pc. Videogames inspired by medical practises or diseases has been discussed on this blog before but I don’t think that this particular game has been mentioned. In the game one takes on the role of a surgeon (or a surgeon’s assistant, I’m a bit in the dark on that one) and I must admit that I found the game to be surprisingly unpleasant.
I guess that working at a place like Medical Museion one gets hardened by telling stories of how the medieval surgeons performed their work or how the cholera epidemic infected people in the middle of the 19th century. Nevertheless this game, where one gets to perform surgery on a knee, really struck me. One thing is the images of the opened knee but I believe that it’s really the sound on the game that gets to me. Especially the sound of the saw going through the knee is really disturbing. Urg!
I must admit that I found it rather educational and apparently my patient survived. To be quite honest I’m not sure that it’s possible to actually ever fail. The game also reminded me of an article I read recently (“Inscribing surgery in digital culture” by Jan Eric Olsén, Årsskrift for Medicinsk Museion, vol. 3, 2006: 49), in which he links computer gaming and virtual surgery:
Future surgery may not require knowledge in handling the scalpel but rather familiarity with computers. It has also been suggested that surgeons who often play computer games sharpen their ability to coordinate the senses of vision and touch, when performing keyhole surgery (Satava ed 1998: 143-144)
That might be right, but I’m quite sure that the above-mentioned game does not train the necessary skills :) (For an online article about the link between surgery and computer gaming click here)
16 Oct 2009 Jonas Paludan

Interesting blog and very educational game – though I’m not so sure I would call the virtual surgery a game, it’s more like an interactive cartoon with instructions for performing surgery on a knee. But I definitely agree that it gets to you to see how a knee surgery is performed – even without sound!
The virtual surgery also makes a very fine point as to why prostheses have been linked to cyborgs! The shaping of the knee joints, cutting off parts to make it almost look like a tool in itself, then attaching new, replaceable metal and plastic parts, turns the knee into something rather different than before and much more robot-like.
I wonder also if ‘games’ like this one is being used for educational purposes in health science studies today? And I wonder if it could be adapted to history of medicine museum purposes too? A series of historical interactive virtual knee operations from different decades in the 20th century (or other kinds of surgery and settings)…
There are a lot of games similar to the Edheads knee game that you mention. These include (all from Edheads).
Hip Replacement
Hip Resurfacing
Deep Brain Stimulation
There are also at least 3 separate heart operation games from charities and educational groups. You can find a comprehensive list on my site if click on the link above (my name).
Hi Will
Thank you for this. Fun games :)